I'm just going to be honest... Rosie O'Grady's is not my type of place. It's a sports bar and while I think it's a fine place for sports people, it's not a great place for me. I'm not a huge sports fan. OK, I'm not a fan of the sports at all. So, this place doesn't have a huge draw for me. However, it's great for work events and Friday work outings. I have eaten a good amount of their food and the only things I think are worth mentioning are their bacon cheddar burger and their pizzas. They seem to be consistently good. Everything else you can get better and cheaper at your local Coney Island. I know, that sounds harsh, but I quite like Coney Island... oh wait, that was harsh to Rosies... welp. The truth hurts sometimes.
Recommendation: Get a pizza. Get the burger (medium rare - even if you like it medium. They overcook). That is all.
Rosie O'Grady's Website
Giving you a taste of what I taste. From gourmet to everyday. No pretentious bull - just good food.